Jaser Alsharhan
04-14-13
P6
“The Sudanese from Kakuma were being sent all over the
globe, and we knew that our fates were not ours to determine” (Eggers 113).
Deng, as one of the many refugees from Sudan, has a story
to tell. One has to just be willing to listen…
One thing to remember throughout this blog post: There is
an air of innocuousness when considering Deng’s story.
It is almost as if his helplessness compels the reader into a state of similar—if not replicated—helplessness when thinking of how or she can enact change, tell others, or just purely help. It has been said that “The most helpless of people are those people with the most power. They can persuade, garner, proselytize, and transform.” I feel that this quote is directly applicable to Deng: he accentuates his own suffering by removing himself entirely from the discernment of his own destiny. By portraying this semblance of innocuousness and pure innocence, Eggers highlights the puppeteering nature of life in What is the What.
Indefinitely, the reader (who has previously read Of Beetles and Angels) is trapped between the seemingly indomitable optimism and strength of Asgedom and the helpless, frayed, and innocent existence of Valentino (short notice: I may switch back-and-forth between his birth-name, Deng, and his Catholic-Baptism name, Valentino, because he normally associates with both names). This juxtaposition is then complimented with Valentino’s deplorable experience in America, the land of supposed “opportunities.” He states, “ But at this moment, when the woman is in my bedroom and the man is guarding me with his gun, I want to be in Kakuma, where I lived in a hut of plastic and sandbags and owned one pair of pants” (Eggers 4). Eggers and his main character pose the question as to whether it is truly beneficial for a refugee to move from his or her homestead and acculturate the “American” way. We use the word “civilize” incessantly when considering refugees coming from another country, but there is no exemplar of true “civilized civilization” when thinking of the United States.
It is almost as if his helplessness compels the reader into a state of similar—if not replicated—helplessness when thinking of how or she can enact change, tell others, or just purely help. It has been said that “The most helpless of people are those people with the most power. They can persuade, garner, proselytize, and transform.” I feel that this quote is directly applicable to Deng: he accentuates his own suffering by removing himself entirely from the discernment of his own destiny. By portraying this semblance of innocuousness and pure innocence, Eggers highlights the puppeteering nature of life in What is the What.
Indefinitely, the reader (who has previously read Of Beetles and Angels) is trapped between the seemingly indomitable optimism and strength of Asgedom and the helpless, frayed, and innocent existence of Valentino (short notice: I may switch back-and-forth between his birth-name, Deng, and his Catholic-Baptism name, Valentino, because he normally associates with both names). This juxtaposition is then complimented with Valentino’s deplorable experience in America, the land of supposed “opportunities.” He states, “ But at this moment, when the woman is in my bedroom and the man is guarding me with his gun, I want to be in Kakuma, where I lived in a hut of plastic and sandbags and owned one pair of pants” (Eggers 4). Eggers and his main character pose the question as to whether it is truly beneficial for a refugee to move from his or her homestead and acculturate the “American” way. We use the word “civilize” incessantly when considering refugees coming from another country, but there is no exemplar of true “civilized civilization” when thinking of the United States.
In direct contrast, the documentary God Grew Tired of Us focuses on the beautiful opportunities present
within the United States without questioning whether this life is better than
the past. There is no parallel to Deng’s flashbacks and recounts of him running
from the rebellious Arabs from the North or his struggle to openly identify
with his Dinka tribe. Both God Grew Tired
of Us and Asgedom’s Of Beetles and Angels disseminate rich stories of hope,
prosperity, survival, and opportunity. Meanwhile, What is the What evokes uncomfortable and nebulous concepts of helplessness, insecurity,
racism, and abuse. Another contrast to
make: religion. While Asgedom’s memoir focuses on the angels in life who can
truly make a difference and alter the course of history positively, What is the What looks to God and the
nature of religion negatively, only blaming the “master puppeteer” for the widespread
calamities which plague the refugees from Khartoum. Several metaphors
supplement this point: the burning of the church in Khartoum, no semblance of organized
religion in America by refugees, and an overall distaste for lack of personal
control over destiny.
The double-entendre of refugees and those of a civilized,
first-world nature:
On page 63 of What
is the What, Eggers introduces an allegory which clearly represents the
definite cultural difference between those of a “civilized nation” and those of
a refugee origin. The story starts with the Dinka who are given the cattle
first, superior land, fertile and rich. The Arabs are forced to suffer through
the desert without “water or arable soil” by God’s decree. The Arabs eventually
steal the cattle, only to butcher them and never really understand the true
value of the cattle. This legend serves two distinct purposes: (1) clearly define
the northern Arabs from the Southern Dinka, and (2) show the manner in which
First-World Citizens (especially those from the United States) abuse the
bounty, resources, and opportunity which they have attained.
This relationship and contrast between the “have” and the “have-nots”
was clearly set-up in both God Grew Tired
of Us and Of Beetles and Angels;
however, the exploration of such cultures and the misuse of power is cemented
within What is the What. Yes, Asgedom
and the Lost Boys of Sudan do a great job of pinpointing the pitfalls of
American culture. In consideration to Deng’s story, the plot ultimately
surrounds the robbing and flashbacks
of deplorable scenes from his childhood. The parallels drawn between his
present and past lives are evident and the comparisons/contrast between the two
are more than ready to be analyzed. Moreover, a reader must dissuade himself or
herself from becoming too enraptured by the conflict of fate and destiny within
the novel. As fate becomes a product of
the puppeteer, the reader is forced to look at the situation with a new paradigmatic
question: is it just meant to be? And the answer...yes, it may just be that
certain individuals are handed better “fates” than others. However, it does not
diminish one’s duty to seek social equity, personal sovereignty, and peaceful
longevity.
“The Sudanese from Kakuma were being sent all over the
globe, and we knew that our fates were not ours to determine” (Eggers 113).
Peace and Blessings!
Jaser
No comments:
Post a Comment